AdvertiseDonate
Sunday, November 15, 2026Local news for Bucks County, Pennsylvania.
Bucks County Tribune · 196 West Ashland Street, Doylestown, PA 18901
News · Miami-Dade

Insurance firm pays tow bill for car recovered from canal after 30 years

A South Florida driver had to intervene to clear a lien placed by a towing company on a vehicle she had insured and surrendered more than three decades ago.

By Charles Reed ·

Illustration for: Insurance firm pays tow bill for car recovered from canal after 30 years
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

Jan Schill was trying to renew her vehicle registration in South Florida when she discovered a financial hold on her license plate. The lien belonged to a towing company that had recovered a car from a canal. The car in question was a 1992 Mercedes 300 Diesel that Schill had owned in the early 1990s. She had reported it stolen and received a payout from her insurer more than 30 years prior.

Schill said she parked the car in her driveway and woke up to find it gone. The vehicle was never located at the time. She surrendered the title to her insurance company and accepted a check for the car's value. She believed the matter was closed until a sheriff's office contacted her in 2025. The officials informed her that the Mercedes had been found at the bottom of a canal.

Schill told the officials she no longer owned the vehicle. She had signed the title over to the insurance carrier after the total loss. She assumed the recovery process was complete. Months later, the issue resurfaced during her tag renewal. A towing company that pulled the car from the water had placed a lien against Schill's name. She was told the lien was for the recovery of the 1992 Mercedes.

Howard Finkelstein of the Help Me Howard program explained the legal responsibility for the debt. He stated that because the insurance company declared the car a total loss and paid Schill, the insurer became the owner of the vehicle. Therefore, the insurance company owed the towing fee, not the original owner. Finkelstein noted that the insurer held the title when the car was recovered.

Schill contacted her insurance company regarding the unexpected charge. The insurer acknowledged the debt and sent a payment to the towing company that same week. Once the tow operator received the funds, they lifted the lien from Schill's record. Schill was then able to complete her registration renewal. She described the process as a merry-go-round that she could not have resolved on her own.

The resolution came within 24 hours of the insurance company receiving the alert. Schill confirmed her tags are now current. She continues to drive in the area where she was born and raised. Finkelstein advised other drivers to ask their insurers for proof that the Department of Motor Vehicles was notified of a change in ownership after a total loss.

More News · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Bucks County Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Bucks County Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.