Two Indiana Races Tighten as Election Day Approaches
Rating changes this week put the secretary of state contest and the 5th District seat closer than expected, with both parties pointing to turnout as the deciding factor.
By Lucia Herrera ·

The ballot lines in two Indiana contests shifted this week, leaving both parties counting on voters who have not yet shown up.
Sabato's Crystal Ball, published by the University of Virginia Center for Politics, moved the secretary of state race from tossup to Lean D on Thursday. The contest features Republican Max Engling, Democrat Beau Bayh, Libertarian Lauri Shillings, and Lincoln Party candidate Greg Ballard.
The Cook Political Report followed on Friday, lowering its rating for Indiana's 5th Congressional District from Likely R to Lean R. That change was one of 12 House seats the report adjusted toward Democrats in its final rating revisions before Election Day. The district, represented by Republican Victoria Spartz, is rated R+8, the only Indiana district without a double-digit Republican lead in average presidential results over the past two elections. Spartz faces Democrat J.D. Ford, with no third-party candidates on the ballot. Earlier this year, the report had rated the seat Solid R.
Mario Massillamany, chair of the Hamilton County Republican Party and a contributor to All INdiana Politics, said early voting tells little because Republicans cast ballots later than Democrats. He predicted Engling would win but said Ballard could draw votes the Republican needs. "What we need is Republicans to show up and vote," Massillamany said. "There are more Republicans. The problem is getting them excited, getting them energized and getting them to show up to vote."
Democratic strategist Lara Beck, also an All INdiana Politics contributor, said Bayh has run a disciplined campaign while Republicans fought among themselves. Engling mounted a last-minute bid in May and unseated incumbent Secretary of State Diego Morales at the state party convention in June. "When you look at that, it has been so negative, and all that negativity is out in the public domain," Beck said. "It's not just being done behind the scenes; it's out front and center." She said Bayh has been able to keep a lead others have found difficult to close.
Beck said the 5th District includes the Indianapolis suburbs of Fishers, Carmel, and Westfield, areas that have shifted toward Democrats in recent elections. Massillamany said Spartz has waited too long to challenge Ford's record. "He has a history and he has a legacy of having bad votes that are not for Hoosiers, nor are they for the 5th District," Massillamany said. "I think (Spartz) has done a really poor job in defining J.D. Ford."
Both also pointed to four Indiana House seats to watch Tuesday: Republican incumbents Becky Cash and Danny Lopez in Carmel, Hunter Smith in Zionsville, and Chris Jeter in Fishers. Democrats need to flip four seats to break the Republican supermajority in the House and have targeted those races in Indianapolis' northern suburbs.
Election Day is Tuesday. Polls run from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Voters must be registered and present a valid photo ID issued by Indiana or the federal government. Bureau of Motor Vehicle branches will process ID applications from 8:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Monday and from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Tuesday, and a temporary paper ID from the BMV is accepted.






