Manatee County Libraries Block Voter Guides, Citing Consistency Over Access
Commissioners have not voted on the policy, but staff are enforcing a 2017 memo that treats nonpartisan guides as political display material.
By Lucia Herrera ·

The League of Women Voters of Manatee County learned in October that its nonpartisan voter guides are no longer welcome in county public libraries. This marks the first time the organization has been barred from distributing the printed materials in these facilities. The guides, which were available in county-owned libraries through 2024, contain general voter information and verbatim responses from local candidates without any endorsements.
Ruth Harenchar, president of the local chapter, raised the issue during public comment at a commission meeting last week. She noted that the guides had been distributed for years without incident. Harenchar stated that restrictions on civic information and educational programming have increased in recent years without public discussion or board approval. She urged commissioners to reconsider the policy in a public forum.
County spokesperson Casey Zempel defended the decision by citing a long-standing policy on political display material. The policy aims to maintain consistent, viewpoint-neutral standards for outside organizations using public facilities. Zempel pointed to a 2017 memorandum from the county attorney's office that addressed political petitioning and campaigning in libraries. The county now applies those same restrictions to library displays.
Zempel emphasized that the goal is not to single out the League of Women Voters or discourage civic participation. The county seeks to manage facilities fairly while allowing staff to focus on resident services. Emails between the League and county staff show that volunteers were also prohibited from hanging flyers for informational events on 2026 constitutional amendments due to their political nature.
Commissioners discussed the policy at a regular meeting on July 28, though they never voted on it. Chairman Tal Siddique echoed concerns from the county attorney that allowing one nonprofit to distribute materials would require allowing every group to do so. He argued that this could burden staff. Siddique suggested it is easier to deny everyone access to the interior space, allowing distribution outside or via websites.
Siddique stated that he favors not allowing any campaign material, whether partisan or nonpartisan, inside the libraries. He acknowledged the free speech argument but preferred the current approach for staff efficiency. Commissioner George Kruse disagreed with Siddique's position. Palm Beach County recently reversed a similar ban on nonpartisan voter guides after public pushback.
The next scheduled step involves the commissioners revisiting the policy in a public forum, as requested by the League. The 2026 primary election is approaching, and the League continues to distribute guides through other channels. The county maintains that the 2017 attorney memo remains the guiding document for library displays.






