Doctors warn against abrupt antidepressant starts without full evaluation
Health experts urge patients to verify underlying causes like thyroid issues and understand withdrawal risks before beginning therapy.
By Mei Lin ·

Healthcare professionals are pushing back against a common assumption that antidepressants serve as a quick fix for persistent low mood. Instead, they emphasize that medication is one tool among several and requires careful medical oversight. The decision to start therapy depends on how long symptoms have lasted and how deeply they disrupt daily life.
Dr. Rhea Rogers, a board-certified physician, noted that the decision looks different for every patient. She advised individuals to recognize signs such as loss of sleep, loss of energy, or loss of motivation. Rogers said that if quality of life is being affected, it is time to look into antidepressant therapy. She added that some people experience a triggering event that starts a downward spiral they cannot pull themselves out of.
Experts caution that these medications do not eliminate sadness. Rogers stated, “They’re not happy pills. They don’t take away the sadness, but they will be a way for you to work on how you got there or what else is going on.” She cited chronic stress, thyroid imbalance, and nutritional deficiencies as examples of underlying factors that might be contributing to the condition.
Gerontologist Sam Cradduck agreed that medication does not change the external circumstance. Cradduck explained that the drugs change the chemical imbalance in the brain to help patients reach a better state. She emphasized that a pill alone is not enough. “But you can’t just take a pill and be done,” Cradduck said. She noted that talk therapy is part of the process and does not always have to involve a therapist. The conversation must address the issues that led to the low mood to prevent a cycle of recurring symptoms.
Aging expert Amy O’Rourke recommended finding a qualified psychiatrist for a thorough assessment. This evaluation helps determine whether to take an antidepressant, which specific drug to use, and the appropriate dose. O’Rourke also advised patients to track how the medication affects them. She described a client who was prescribed an antidepressant and felt like she was having a panic attack, with a racing heartbeat and sweating. The client called her psychiatrist, who discontinued the medication and prescribed a different one.
O’Rourke said patients should know the withdrawal symptoms before starting any antidepressant. Rogers agreed that there are many withdrawal symptoms associated with these drugs. “You cannot just stop it all of a sudden,” Rogers said. She noted that people do not all respond to the same drugs. Rogers said that if patients can afford it, finding out their genetic variations is one investment worth making because it can help them respond better to their situation.
Aging well coach Katherine Ambrose mentioned talk therapy, journaling, and filling the mind with positivity as support mechanisms alongside medical help. Rogers added that patients should not forget about things like their thyroid, hormones, or nutrients. Ambrose encouraged patients to talk to their doctors, seek answers, and get their rebound. “Try everything you can because it’s worth bringing yourself back,” Ambrose said.
The group of experts noted that it does not have to be one isolated thing that brought a person to this point. They stressed the importance of a comprehensive approach rather than relying on a single intervention. Patients are encouraged to consult with licensed physicians to diagnose and treat health problems. Those seeking personal medical advice should always seek the advice of their doctor or other qualified health provider regarding a medical condition.
The information provided by these professionals is for educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute providing medical advice or professional services. The information should not be used for diagnosing or treating a health problem or disease without professional consultation. If a person thinks they may have a medical emergency, they should call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room immediately.






