Environment Secretary summons water chiefs after record low performance scores
A joint regulatory report rates eight of nine English water companies as poor or needing improvement, with pollution incidents remaining high despite billions in investment.
By Charles Reed ·

Angela Eagle, the environment secretary, has called senior executives from the water industry to Whitehall to discuss a new report on environmental performance. The meeting follows the release of a joint assessment that found the sector’s performance has declined despite substantial financial input.
The report rates eight of the nine water companies operating in England as either "poor" or "requiring improvement." Only one company avoided these lower ratings. The assessment was produced jointly by the Environment Agency, the Drinking Water Inspectorate, Natural Resources Wales, and Ofwat.
Eagle stated that the public has grown weary of explanations for ongoing issues. "People are sick of excuses," she said. She warned that further changes could be imposed on the industry if performance does not improve.
The data shows 74 serious pollution incidents in the recent period. These are incidents categorized as causing significant harm to the environment. This total is only one fewer than the previous year. The report notes this stability in serious incidents occurred despite billions of pounds in investment and bans on executive bonuses.
The watchdogs' environmental performance assessment ratings totalled 16 stars out of a possible 36. This represents a drop from 19 stars the previous year. It is the lowest score recorded since the assessment process began.
Defra indicated that Eagle is preparing to take further action. This includes imposing tougher consequences for executives at failing companies. The department plans to set out a clear set of improvement actions. These actions will focus on tackling leakage, reducing pollution incidents, and improving customer satisfaction. Rules that took effect last year already block bonuses for executives at companies receiving a one-star rating.
Context for these findings includes the fact that the UK is one of only two countries where water provision is fully privatised. The other is Chile, where privatisation was implemented in the 1980s under a military dictatorship. Overall, there were 2,666 pollution incidents in England in 2025. This figure represents a 40 percent increase on the 2016 total, according to the Environment Agency.
Thames Water recorded the highest number of incidents, followed by Anglian Water, United Utilities, Yorkshire Water, and Southern Water. James Wallace, chief executive of River Action, argued that the system currently rewards shareholders and creditors while rivers, wildlife, and bill payers lose out. He stated that Thames Water ought to go into special administration immediately and called for ministers to review alternative models including public ownership.
Richard Benwell, chief executive of Wildlife and Countryside Link, said a new regulator must be more than a merger of existing institutions. He noted the need for a clear legal duty to restore nature and strong environmental targets. Water UK, the industry trade body, stated that the report shows the lowest level of leakage in history. It acknowledged that environmental performance is not good enough for some companies but argued that record investment will help secure water supplies and end sewage entering rivers and seas.
More Business · Customer Complaints · Report a business · Got a Story?






