Research indicates Americans agree on more political issues than they think
A new study by Pew Research Center suggests that a 'messy middle' comprising 60 percent of the electorate shares values that cross traditional party lines.
By Charles Reed ·

Political scientists have long argued that the United States is deeply divided, yet recent data suggests the actual gap between the left and right is narrower than public perception. New findings from the Pew Research Center challenge the idea that Americans live in two separate ideological camps. Instead, the data points to a large, complex center where voters share common ground regardless of their party registration.
The core of this argument rests on the behavior of voters who rarely discuss politics with friends or family. Shanna Berry, a retired hairdresser and Air Force veteran in Houston, and Alma Ong, a liberal Buddhist in Edgewater, Maryland, are examples of this dynamic. The pair avoided political conversation until January, when they discussed the U.S. capture of Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro. Berry, who supported Donald Trump, expressed uncertainty about the legal basis of the action but noted the oil interests involved. Ong, who dislikes the president, was surprised to find she agreed with Berry on almost every point.
Kristin Laurin, a psychology professor at the University of British Columbia, says this interaction reflects a broader trend. People often overestimate their differences with those on the other side of the aisle because they avoid direct conversation. Politicians and social media platforms amplify extreme voices to drive engagement, creating a perception of total war that does not match the daily views of most citizens.
This disconnect is visible in recent national events. In April, former FBI Director James Comey was indicted by the Department of Justice for posting a photo of seashells that officials claimed was a death threat against the president. The move drew criticism from both parties. Jonathan Turley, a constitutional law professor at George Washington University Law School, expressed disbelief at the legal reasoning, while Stan Fletcher, a Trump supporter and restaurateur in Maryland, argued that no one should be indicted for an opinion.
Pew Research Center categorizes the American electorate into nine distinct groups based on values and attitudes. One such group, the Pragmatic and Polite Right, values civility and holds conservative economic views but is more moderate on race and immigration. Within this group, 56 percent identify as Republicans or lean Republican, while 37 percent identify as Democrats or lean Democrat. Jocelyn Kiley, who leads politics research at Pew, notes that this overlap demonstrates significant variation within party labels.
The center of this political spectrum is vast. Pew estimates that the messy middle accounts for approximately 60 percent of the electorate. In contrast, the most ideologically distinct groups, the No Apologies Right and the Faith First Conservatives, make up only 21 percent of the population. Kiley stated that while polarization is real, the nuance beneath the headlines is often ignored. The research suggests that the loud voices on either end of the spectrum do not represent the full diversity of American political thought.






