Norwalk City Council: FOIC Hearing May Settle Mayor's Caucus Status
A new complaint challenges decades of practice allowing Mayor Barbara Smyth to attend closed-door party meetings, citing gaps in the city charter.
By Charles Reed ·

Norwalk City Council members and Mayor Barbara Smyth have held twelve closed-door meetings from January to June of this year.
Connecticut’s Freedom of Information Act allows members of the same political party within a public body to meet in private to discuss party issues. This exemption applies even if the group constitutes a quorum, provided the discussion remains limited to party matters.
For more than forty years, Norwalk mayors have attended these caucuses. However, council members have questioned whether the mayor is legally entitled to be present during these sessions. The legal status of the mayor’s participation has remained formally unresolved for decades.
On June 23, the city hosted a training on state freedom of information laws. During the session, Council Member James Frayer asked a commission official if the mayor could attend council caucuses. Russel Blair, the Director of Education and Communications for the Freedom of Information Commission, stated that if the mayor is not an ex officio member of the council, the agency does not consider them a member. Consequently, Blair argued, they would not be privileged to join the caucus.
Council Member Jalin Sead Sr. pressed for a more definitive answer, noting that the mayor casts a tie-breaking vote. Blair explained that the final determination depends on the Norwalk Charter. He suggested the city consult its corporation counsel, adding that the commission would need to review the charter if a formal complaint were filed.
The city website identifies the council as the legislative branch of government. It lists fifteen elected members: five at-large and two from each of the five districts. Section 3-4A of the Charter outlines this structure but does not mention the mayor. Despite this omission, Corporation Counsel Mario Coppola and Deputy Corporation Counsel Jeffry Spahr maintain that the mayor is an ex officio member by virtue of the office.
Spahr cited Chapter V of the Charter, which charges the mayor with presiding at all council meetings and grants the power to vote in the event of a tie. He argued that these duties make the mayor a member of the Common Council. The city also pointed to a 1982 legal opinion by then-Corporation Counsel John J. Ryan, which deemed the mayor's presence in caucus both appropriate and desirable. That opinion was written after a secret meeting between Republican and Conservative council members, then-Mayor Thomas O’Connor, and city officials violated open-meetings laws.
In that 1982 incident, O’Connor admitted he was unaware the law forbade his attendance. City Clerk James R. Cunningham disagreed with Ryan’s assessment. Cunningham told newspapers that the statute clearly prohibited the mayor’s presence because the charter specifically excluded the mayor from participating in council affairs. He later wrote to the FOIC seeking an advisory ruling but the commission declined to issue one. Executive Director Mitchell W. Pearlman stated that there were too many variables to answer the question flatly and that a contested case would be the best path forward.
Norwalk Current, the local news site that filed the complaint, searched FOIC records and found no previous contested case or formal complaint on this issue. The organization filed its complaint in June, potentially making it the first formal challenge to the mayor’s caucus participation. As of publication, the hearing has not yet been scheduled.






