Governor Orders Probe Into Senate Spoiler Efforts
Alaska’s top executive is directing a state investigation after media reports that Democratic strategists sought to recruit a rival candidate with the same name as the Republican incumbent.
By Mei Lin ·

Alaska Governor Mike Dunleavy ordered the Department of Public Safety to investigate the U.S. Senate race on Wednesday night. The directive follows a New York Times report alleging that Democratic campaign operatives attempted to recruit a spoiler candidate. The candidate, a non-incumbent named Dan Sullivan, shares the same name as the Republican incumbent holding the seat. The state’s toss-up election could determine which party controls the Senate next year.
The conflict centers on whether the presence of two candidates with identical names on the ballot could confuse voters or siphon support from the incumbent. Democrats have long denied involvement in the non-incumbent Sullivan’s candidacy. Both the campaign of former congresswoman Mary Peltola and the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee reiterated those denials after the New York Times story published. The report was based on interviews and communications among Peltola’s attorneys, advisers, and senior DSCC aides.
The dispute over the ballot has roots in Alaska’s nonpartisan primary system. That system advances the top four vote-getters to the general election. The non-incumbent Sullivan advanced through that process. State officials probed the candidacies previously. The Alaska Supreme Court ruled in June that the non-incumbent Sullivan could appear on the general election ballot. The court’s decision cleared the path for his name to be printed alongside the incumbent’s.
President Trump reacted swiftly to the reporting. He called the situation "Voter Fraud at the Highest Level" in an online post. Nate Adams, a spokesperson for Sen. Sullivan, accused the Peltola campaign of gaslighting Alaskans. Adams stated that the campaign spent months denying a scheme it was running. Peltola called the story a distraction while campaigning on Wednesday. The non-incumbent Sullivan did not respond to requests for comment but has previously stated that running for Senate was his decision.
The Justice Department under President Trump had already sought to intervene in the race. Last week, the department asked a court to delay certification if the incumbent Sullivan loses by a small margin. The legal effort cited potential voter confusion stemming from the second Sullivan on the ballot. Election law experts broadly criticized the DOJ’s case as weak. They noted that the Constitution grants states control over elections. Justice Department officials said the New York Times story expands the department’s options for investigation. The department filed an amended complaint citing the new reporting.
Gov. Dunleavy’s directive asks the Department of Public Safety to investigate whether the scheme violated Alaska laws. The governor also asked whether criminal charges or civil action are warranted. It remains unclear which specific laws could have been violated. Elaine Kamarck, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, noted that trickery is common in politics. She said the internet makes it easy to spread both tricks and corrections. Kamarck described such maneuvers as standard fare for campaigns.
Some voters compared the reporting to Republican groups spending to support a Democrat on Alaska’s U.S. House ballot. That Democrat is currently a federal prisoner in New York. Reactions to the new reporting were mixed. Some residents expressed frustration that the story draws attention from other issues. Others expressed skepticism that voters would be confused. The ballot notes which Sullivan is the Republican incumbent. The state uses ranked-choice voting for the general election. Voters can rank both Sullivans if they are confused, provided they do not rank Peltola.
The general election ballot also includes a question on whether voters want to keep the state’s unique election system. Election Day is scheduled for November 3. The investigation ordered by the governor is expected to proceed in parallel with the final campaign days. No timeline was provided for the completion of the Department of Public Safety’s review. The two Sullivans will both appear on the ballot unless a court intervenes again.






