AdvertiseDonate
Sunday, November 15, 2026Local news for Bucks County, Pennsylvania.
Bucks County Tribune · 196 West Ashland Street, Doylestown, PA 18901

Carnegie Land Swap: Park Service Proposal Draws 12,500 Comments

A plan to trade federal land for private property on Cumberland Island would allow up to eight new homes while securing coastal protection.

By Lucia Herrera ·

Illustration for: Carnegie Land Swap: Park Service Proposal Draws 12,500 Comments
Illustration generated for this article, not a news photograph.

A proposed land swap between the National Park Service and descendants of industrialist Thomas Carnegie would allow up to eight new private homes on Cumberland Island. The exchange, currently under public review, aims to bring privately held land on the island's Atlantic side under federal protection. In return, two branches of the Carnegie family would receive parkland overlooking a salt marsh and Cumberland Sound. Park Service officials say this arrangement would concentrate private ownership on the island's western side.

Cumberland Island is an 18-mile barrier island in Georgia that has been managed as a national seashore since 1972. The site includes approximately 9,800 acres of congressionally designated wilderness, salt marshes, and maritime forests. Public access is limited to ferry service, and the island supports populations of wild horses, feral hogs, and deer. The land holds historical significance, including Native American artifacts, Spanish mission remnants, and homes built by Thomas Carnegie and his wife, Lucy.

Park Superintendent Melissa Trenchik stated that development remains possible on the private property if the exchange does not proceed. The proposed homes would face permanent conservation restrictions and a height limit of 35 feet. The proposal has generated significant public interest, drawing more than 12,500 comments. Opponents question the description of the houses as modest, noting that the allowance for 15,000 square feet includes driveways and outbuildings.

Joseph Manning, an attorney for Defenders of Wildlife, argues the exchange benefits a small number of families rather than expanding public access. Barclay McFadden, a great-great-grandson of Thomas Carnegie involved in the deal, says the proposal provides homes for younger generations. He points to the family's longstanding attachment to the island, noting that a cemetery there holds five generations. McFadden said his grandmother's generation protected the island by declining opportunities to sell to developers in the 1970s.

Jamie Ferguson, a cousin of McFadden who is not directly involved in the proposal, emphasizes the family's role in stewardship. Ferguson shares ownership of the Greyfield Inn, a Carnegie mansion operating as a bed and breakfast, with about 40 others. He believes preserving the island requires attention to its cultural history as well as its natural environment. Ferguson sees potential for improved visitor access to The Chimneys, remnants of roughly two dozen brick and tabby chimneys marking homes where enslaved workers lived on a cotton plantation before the Carnegies arrived.

Naturalist Carol Ruckdeschel, 85, opposes the exchange, viewing it as a possible opening for further development. A resident for more than 50 years, Ruckdeschel continues weekly beach surveys for stranded sea turtles and new nests. She also opposes a separate Park Service plan to double daily visitation to 700 people. Ruckdeschel acknowledges the Carnegie descendants' affection for the island but believes additional homes and visitors would disrupt the primitive wilderness. Having watched maritime forest reclaim former cotton fields, she hopes more of the island can return to nature.

More News · National news · Report a business · Got a Story?

Get Bucks County Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.

Get Bucks County Tribune in your inboxLocal news for Bucks County, Pennsylvania. Free, a few times a week, unsubscribe any time.