Big 12 Concedes Replay Error Gave BYU False Touchdown
The conference admitted a first-quarter score against Arizona State was incorrect, marking the third straight week of officiating disputes for the Cougars.
By Charles Reed ·

The Big 12 Conference officially acknowledged an officiating mistake during No. 8 BYU's 27-20 victory over Arizona State on Saturday. The error involved a first-quarter touchdown that should not have been awarded to the Cougars.
On BYU's opening drive, quarterback Bear Bachmeier attempted a run from the one-yard line. He fumbled the ball, and running back Sione Moa recovered it to cross the goal line. Officials initially stopped the play, ruling Bachmeier down with forward progress. A subsequent review led replay operations to declare the fumble recovered for a touchdown.
The conference later stated the ball should have been spotted at the two-yard line. This ruling aligns with Rule 12-3-3-d-2, which dictates that if a ball is recovered while live, it belongs to the recovering team at the spot of recovery. Any further advance is nullified. The Big 12 noted that replay was incorrect in awarding the score and that the proper ruling was third-and-goal from the two-yard line.
Arizona State head coach Kenny Dillingham contested the decision on the field. He argued that while Bachmeier could recover the ball after the whistle, it did not constitute a clear advancement. Dillingham maintained the ball should have been placed at the three-yard line. He expressed disappointment but emphasized that the on-field officials were not at fault, noting that the decision originated from the replay center in Irving, Texas.
This incident is the third consecutive week that a BYU game has featured disputed officiating calls. Following the Cougars' 28-24 win over Notre Dame on Oct. 17, the Big 12 determined one second should have been added to the clock to allow a final offensive play. The previous week, BYU lost 39-31 to UCF in double overtime after a blocked field goal. Officials ruled a 10-second runoff was triggered when UCF kicker Will Stone's helmet came off, eliminating a potential second attempt for a winning kick.
The correction changes the theoretical outcome of the possession but does not alter the final result of the Arizona State game. The conference's admission confirms that the touchdown was a product of the replay process rather than the initial judgment of the game officials.






